Book Consultation

Book a Consultation

Preaward Survey Failures- Part 1

November 19, 2026

What’s in This Article:

Understanding the Most Common Preaward Survey Failures

Labor Distribution

Policies and Procedures

How to Prepare for a Preaward Accounting System Survey

Frequently Asked Questions

Understanding the Most Common Preaward Survey Failures

A preaward accounting system survey can be an important step for government contractors pursuing certain types of federal contracts. But what causes contractors to fail these evaluations?

A preaward accounting system survey evaluates whether a prospective contractor’s accounting system is suitably designed to accumulate, segregate, and report costs under government contracts.

The evaluation is documented using Standard Form 1408 (SF 1408), which addresses accounting system criteria such as labor distribution, segregation of costs, indirect cost allocation, and timekeeping.

Under FAR 9.106, preaward surveys may be requested when additional information is needed to determine a prospective contractor’s responsibility. The accounting system evaluation is one component that may be considered.

For cost-reimbursement contracts, FAR 16.301-3 requires the contractor’s accounting system to be adequate for determining costs applicable to the contract or order.

A preaward accounting system survey may also be relevant to other contract types, depending on the solicitation and applicable requirements.

An unfavorable accounting system evaluation can delay or jeopardize a contract award when an adequate system is required.

In my experience, five common areas of concern are labor distribution, policies and procedures, generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), segregation of costs, and indirect cost rates.

This is Part 1 of our two-part series. We’ll begin with the first two areas where government contractors frequently encounter problems.

Labor Distribution

Labor distribution is one of the most important areas evaluated during a preaward accounting system survey.

At least two items on the SF 1408 checklist address labor: timekeeping and labor distribution.

The distribution of labor costs to contracts and non-contract activities is a key concern for government auditors because the government should only be charged for costs properly attributable to its contracts.

Contractors need an accounting system designed to support accurate recording and allocation of employee labor.

Under the DCAA Preaward Accounting System Survey Audit Program, the evaluation includes determining whether the system is designed to support employee-certified timesheets, supervisory approvals, and reconciliation of labor distribution records to payroll and accounting records.

Common labor distribution problems include:

  • Employees failing to record all hours worked

  • Time charged to the wrong contract or cost objective

  • Inadequate identification of direct and indirect labor

  • Labor distribution records that do not reconcile to payroll

  • Missing employee certifications or supervisory approvals

  • Labor adjustments made without sufficient documentation

Why Recording All Hours Matters

Contractors that fail to record all hours worked, whether on a contract or performing indirect activities, risk misstating labor costs and indirect cost rates.

For example, if a contractor uses labor hours as an allocation base and fails to record certain hours, the resulting indirect cost rate may be overstated.

The effect depends on the contractor’s cost accounting methodology and how labor costs and hours are accumulated.

This concern is particularly important for salaried employees who may work more than their standard schedule.

Under FAR 52.237-10 – Identification of Uncompensated Overtime, certain professional and technical service solicitations require contractors to identify uncompensated overtime and use adjusted hourly rates in their proposals.

Uncompensated overtime generally refers to hours worked without additional compensation beyond an average 40-hour workweek by direct-charge employees who are exempt from the Fair Labor Standards Act.

The provision applies when included in the solicitation. It does not automatically apply to every government contract.

Regardless of contract type, contractors should maintain reliable timekeeping procedures that accurately capture labor activity and support the distribution of costs.

Documenting Labor Adjustments

Changes to labor charges are another area of concern for government auditors.

A contractor should be able to explain why a labor adjustment was made, who authorized it, and how the change relates to the employee’s actual work.

For example, if an employee initially charges time to the wrong project, the correction should be supported by appropriate documentation.

Labor adjustments should not be made solely to avoid contract funding shortages, cost overruns, or other financial problems.

Unsupported or intentionally misleading labor charges can create serious compliance risks.

A properly designed accounting system should provide an audit trail for labor corrections and require appropriate review and approval.

Policies and Procedures

Another common preaward survey problem is the absence of adequate accounting policies and procedures.

Although SF 1408 does not contain a separate checklist item titled “Policies and Procedures,” written procedures help demonstrate how a contractor’s accounting system is designed to satisfy the applicable criteria.

There is a saying: “If it’s not in writing, it doesn’t exist.”

While written documentation alone does not establish that a system is adequate, it helps demonstrate consistency and provides a basis for evaluating the contractor’s accounting practices.

The DCAA preaward survey process may include reviewing written policies, procedures, system descriptions, and demonstrations to determine whether the accounting system is suitably designed.

Government contractors should have documented procedures addressing areas such as:

  • Employee timekeeping and labor distribution

  • Identification of direct and indirect costs

  • Allocation of indirect expenses

  • Segregation of unallowable costs

  • Reconciliation of subsidiary records to the general ledger

  • Management review and approval of accounting transactions

  • Corrections to labor and other accounting records

  • Monitoring and reporting contract costs

Accounting Instructions Are Not the Same as Internal Controls

Another area where contractors fail is assuming that accounting processing instructions are the same as internal control policies and procedures.

These are two different things.

Accounting processing instructions explain how employees complete particular tasks, such as entering transactions into accounting software, processing payroll, or generating reports.

Internal control policies and procedures establish the rules, responsibilities, approvals, and safeguards that help ensure accounting information is accurate and reliable.

For example, an accounting instruction may explain how to enter employee hours into a timekeeping system.

An internal control procedure should address who is responsible for entering time, when entries must be completed, who reviews and approves them, and how corrections are documented.

Similarly, a procedure explaining how to post a journal entry is different from a policy establishing who may authorize that entry and what supporting documentation is required.

Both types of documentation are important.

Written policies should also reflect how the contractor’s accounting system is actually designed to operate. Having a manual that does not match the company’s practices may create additional concerns during an evaluation.

How to Prepare for a Preaward Accounting System Survey

Preparation should begin before a contractor receives a request for a preaward accounting system evaluation.

Contractors can reduce the risk of deficiencies by reviewing their accounting system design against the applicable SF 1408 criteria.

Important preparation steps include:

  • Reviewing the SF 1408 accounting system criteria

  • Confirming that timekeeping procedures capture and allocate labor appropriately

  • Verifying that labor distribution records can be reconciled to payroll

  • Documenting direct and indirect cost accounting methods

  • Establishing written accounting and internal control procedures

  • Reviewing how unallowable costs are identified and excluded

  • Confirming that the system can accumulate costs by contract

  • Preparing to explain and demonstrate accounting processes

A preaward survey focuses on whether the accounting system is suitably designed for the prospective contract.

According to DCAA’s preaward audit guidance, the evaluation may rely on inquiries, observations, documentation, and walkthroughs. An accounting system does not necessarily need a long operating history to be evaluated, but the contractor must provide sufficient evidence of its design.

Addressing potential deficiencies before an evaluation can help contractors avoid unnecessary delays.

It is also important to understand that a preaward accounting system evaluation is not the same as a comprehensive audit of an operating accounting system. The scope and procedures differ.

For government contractors preparing to pursue cost-reimbursement contracts or other opportunities with accounting system requirements, reviewing these areas early can help establish a stronger foundation.

In Part 2 of this series, we’ll examine the remaining three common problem areas: GAAP, segregation of costs, and indirect cost rates.

At Cheryl Jefferson & Associates, we help government contractors evaluate accounting systems, identify potential compliance gaps, and prepare for government accounting requirements.

Learn more about our GovCon Consulting Services or contact CJA to discuss your accounting system readiness.

Engineering Workspace Time Entry

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an SF 1408 preaward accounting system survey?

It is an evaluation of whether a prospective government contractor’s accounting system is suitably designed to meet the applicable accounting requirements for a proposed contract.

Can a contractor fail a preaward survey because of timekeeping problems?

Yes. Inadequate timekeeping, unsupported labor adjustments, and labor records that cannot be reconciled to payroll may result in accounting system deficiencies.

Are written accounting policies required for a preaward survey?

Written policies and procedures help demonstrate how an accounting system satisfies SF 1408 criteria. Evaluators may review documentation and system demonstrations to determine whether the system is adequately designed.

Guest Contributor

Related Posts

Cost Reimbursement Contracts

Cost Reimbursement Contracts

What’s in This Article: Understanding Cost Reimbursement Contracts Types of Cost Reimbursement Contracts How They Work Accounting Conclusion Frequently Asked Questions Understanding Cost Reimbursement Contracts Cost reimbursement contracts are commonly used in...

Firm Fixed Price Contracts

Firm Fixed Price Contracts

What’s in This Article: Understanding Firm Fixed Price Contracts How Firm Fixed Price Contracts Work Accounting for Firm Fixed Price Contracts Without Separate Deliverables Accounting for Firm Fixed Price Contracts With Deliverables How Payment Terms Affect Contract...

Contract Related Assets and Liabilities

Contract Related Assets and Liabilities

What’s in This Article: Understanding Contract Related Assets and Liabilities Five Common Contract Related Assets and Liabilities Timing Differences Rate Variances Costs in Excess of Billings Billings in Excess of Costs Retainage Why Regular Reconciliation Matters...

Preaward Survey Failures – Part 2

Preaward Survey Failures – Part 2

What’s in This Article: Understanding the Remaining Preaward Survey Failures GAAP Financial Reporting Segregation of Costs Indirect Cost Rates The Passing Measure Frequently Asked Questions Understanding the Remaining Preaward Survey Failures In Part 1 of this series,...